译者按:俄乌战争已经近3年,俄乌双方到底兵力损失有多少,据《乌克兰新声》(The
New Voice of Ukraine)12月3日报道,乌克兰军事专家日罗霍夫认为,现在是公开乌克兰军队伤亡数字的时候了,并说数据透明更为可取。据日罗霍夫推算,俄乌双方伤亡人数计较接近。
(乌克兰首都基辅市中心纪念阵亡军人)
It's time to disclose Ukrainian
military casualties figures, as the secrecy might have a subversive impact on
the country's society, military expert Mykhailo Zhirokhov said in an interview
with Radio NV on Dec. 3.12月3日,军事专家米哈伊洛·日罗霍夫(Mykhailo
Zhirokhov)接受了“乌克兰新声电台”采访,他说,现在是公开乌克兰军队伤亡数字的时候了,因为保密可能会对乌克兰社会产生颠覆性影响。
He made this statement after
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy denied claims by Western media that
80,000 Ukrainian soldiers have been killed during Russia's full-scale invasion,
stating the actual number is "significantly lower" without providing
specifics.据西方媒体报道,在俄罗斯全面入侵期间,有8万乌克兰士兵丧生,乌克兰总统泽连斯基(Volodymyr Zelenskyy)对此进行了否认,称实际数字“大大低于这一数字”,但他没有提供具体细节。针对泽连斯基的说法,日罗霍夫发表了上述言论。
Zhirokhov argued that it's time
to disclose casualty figures, suggesting that transparency is more preferable
nowadays. "The public already has a general understanding of the scale of
losses through local memorials and the personal impact on families," he
said.日罗霍夫说,现在是公布伤亡数字的时候了,表示现在数据透明度更为可取。日罗霍夫说:“通过当地的纪念活动和对家庭的个人影响,公众已经大致了解了损失的规模。”
Zhirokhov estimates Ukrainian
losses to be comparable to Russia's, citing sources indicating 82,000 confirmed
Russian fatalities. He believes official statistics likely include not only
combat deaths but also non-combat losses, missing personnel, and significant
numbers of wounded soldiers.日罗霍夫估计,乌克兰的损失与俄罗斯不相上下,他援引消息来源称,经确认的俄罗斯死亡人数为 8.2 万人。他认为,官方统计数字可能不仅包括战斗死亡人数,还包括非战斗损失、失踪人员和大量伤兵。
A recent report by The Economist
estimated 60,000–100,000 Ukrainian soldiers have died, with an additional
400,000 wounded and unfit for combat. These figures do not account for civilian
casualties, which are believed to number in the tens of thousands.《经济学人》(The Economist)最近的一份报告估计,已有6万至10万名乌克兰士兵死亡,另有40万名伤员不适合参加战斗。这些数字不包括平民伤亡,据认为,平民伤亡人数达数万人。
The Ukrainian General Staff
reports Russian forces have suffered approximately 735,410 casualties — killed
and wounded — since February 2022. In February 2024, Zelenskyy revealed
Ukraine’s irreversible military losses stood at around 31,000.乌克兰总参谋部报告称,自 2022年2月以来,俄罗斯军队伤亡人数约为735410 人——包括死亡和受伤。2024年2月,泽连斯基透露,乌克兰不可逆转的军事损失约为31000人。
On Sept. 17, 2024, the Wall
Street Journal reported that, as a result of Russia's full-scale invasion,
Ukraine had lost 80,000 soldiers killed and approximately 400,000 wounded. On
Sept. 20, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy called these figures false, arguing
that Ukraine's actual losses are significantly lower.2024年9月17日,《华尔街日报》(Wall
Street Journal)报道称,由于俄罗斯的全面入侵,乌克兰已有8万名士兵阵亡,约40万人受伤。9月20日,乌克兰总统泽连斯基称这些数字不实,说乌克兰的实际损失要低得多。