ARDS Global definition

文摘   2024-11-10 08:30   河北  

Happy 50th birthday ARDS!





ARDS 50多年了,它是一个syndrome。



ARDS in China




重症患者的重大难题(Top10疾病负担)



全国临床流行病学调查:

·患病率高
-重症患病率接近10%
-我国每年新发病例110万
·病死率居高不下
-病死率40%
-我国每年死亡约37万
·高致残率/低生活质量
-30-40%遗留行为能力障碍
-6年后仅50%患者恢复原有工作



它的诊断,从1992年欧美ARDS联席会议标准到之后的柏林标准,到今天的global definition,为什么要做这样的新标准?


·The diagnosis of ARDS
-Delayed or missed in two-thirds of patients
-Diagnosis missed entirely in 40% of patients
·ARDS is diagnosed
-Mild ARDS: 51%
-Severe ARDS: 79%



focus on ventilated 

patients

Berlin Definition


“LUNG SAFE”study
·Patients with invasive or noninvasive ventilation
·The oxygenation cut-offs were associated with different mortality
·P/F ratio = Aterial blood gas analysis

即使在ICU里,不给病人抽个血气,诊断ARDS或者分它的程度,都是有困难的。



New ARDS Definition was imperative





·Since 2015, HFNO has become widely used for acute respiratory failure, most recently in patients with severe COVID-19
·HFNO: routine used in ICU

更何况这些年我们越来越多的high flow使用,尤其术后有免疫功能低下的病人,新冠病人就用的更多了。而high flow病人在用的时候,有PEEP吗?血气好像也不太好查,尤其在疫情期间。



上图所示文章告诉我们,为什么柏林标准能让那么多病人没有诊断或者诊断被延迟。原来小于一周,新冠病人很多病程发病一周以后才发生。另外一定要有PEEP。氧合指数小于300mmHg,必须查血气等。这样的一些原因可能都会指向,好像柏林标准是有问题的,所以大家会说应该做一个新的标准。


Evolving definition of ARDS





If a"Better"Definition Is the Answer, What Is the Question?


最早是ESICM,也就是欧洲的重症学会要更新概念和ARDS的guideline。然后,一些美国研究者认为不能在ESICM框架上做definition,要做global。



ARDS VS 

Conceptual model

Key point 1

·ARDS is an acute diffuse, inflammatory lung injury precipitated by a predisposing risk factor such as pneumonia, non-pulmonary infection, trauma, transfusion, burn,aspiration, or shock


·The resulting injury leads to increased pulmonary vascular and epithelial permeability, lung edema, and gravity dependent atelectasis, all of which contribute to loss of aerated lung tissue

-increased lung weight"is no longer included because of limited feasibility of measurement"


·The clinical hallmarks are arterial hypoxemia and diffuse radiographic  opacities  associated  with  increased  shunting , increased alveolar dead space, and decreased lung compliance

-the concept of venous admixture is replaced by increased shunting and increased ratio of physiologic to alveolar dead space


·The clinical presentation is influenced by medical management (position, sedation,paralysis, and fluid balance)


·Histological findings vary and may include intra-alveolar edema, inflammation, hyaline membrane formation, and alveolar hemorrhage

-Not all patients with clinical ARDS have histological findings of diffuse alveolar damage

-it is rare to obtain lung biopsies in patients with ARDS



HFNO ≥30L/min

Key point 2

Timing of Intubation and Clinical Outcomes in Adults With Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome


·Intubated and non-intubated patients with ARDS defined by Acute hypoxemia (P/F≤300 or S/F≤315)

·Bilateral radiographic opacities not explained by cardiac failure

·In 457 patients, 106 (23%) were not intubated at the time of meeting all other ARDS criteria

·Late Intubation >1 day



Early Identification of Acute Respiratory Distress Disorder in the Absence of Positive Pressure Ventilation: Implications for Revision of the Berlin Criteria for Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome

127 patients
·bilateral pulmonary infiltrates
·P/F≤ 300mm Hg under standard oxygen 1 hour after NIV,87% patients kept P/F  300mm Hg



Mechanical ventilation might not be mandatory for patients with ARDS according to the Berlin definition

HFNO generate PEEP for ARDS diagnosis


High flow nasal oxygen generates positive airway pressure in adult volunteers





HFNO(≥40L/min):112
NIV (PEEP≥5 cmH2O):69

Broadening the ARDS definition to include patients on HFNO with P/F≤300mmHg identify patients at earlier stages of disease

Do we really need PEEP for ARDS diagnosis?PEEP>=5cmH2O



Diagnosis of ARDS in patients on HFNO may allow identification of patients at an earlier stage of ARDS

我们用high flow在30L或者40L代替PEEP,似乎临床是可以接受的,至少让病人能够得到早期诊断过度诊断的人并不特别多,而且结局可能是好的。



S/F≤315mmHg 

with SpO2≤97%

Key point 3

·S/F have been validated for diagnosis and management of ARDS

·Many evidences support the use of pulse oximetry-based measurements in the ARDS studies



其中一个非常大的问题,柏林标准说30-40L流量解决PEEP问题。柏林标准另一个突出的问题是,一定要查血气。尤其这三年疫情大家认为饱和度监测可能在床边更实用。即使在ICU里,也可以看到很多病人来了,很快心电监测、饱和度监测就上去了,所以饱和度监测显然要比血气快得多。



Panel: Advantages and disadvantages of SpO2 measurements in ARDS

Advantages
·Continuously available
·Highly sensitive for hypoxaemia
·Easily interpretable
·Non-invasive, no risk of procedural complications
·More readily available than PaO2 in resource-limited settings

Disadvantages
·Measurement error can be increased by conditions commonly seen in the intensive care unit, such as poor
·perfusion and vasopressor use, severe hypoxaemia, or acidaemia
·Potential for reduced accuracy in patients with darker skin pigmentation
·Potential for misclassification of diagnosis or severity in ARDS



SpO2/FiO2 For P/F

·Database from ARDSnet
·Patients with SpO2<97%
·N=672
·Relationship between S/F and P/F

The derivation data set(2,613 measurements)
·S/F=64+0.84XP/F [p<0.0001;r=0.89]
·S/F 235=P/F 200
·S/F 315=P/F 300
The validation database(2,031 measurements)
·S/F 315 =P/F 300, 85% sensitivity with 85% specificity
·S/F 235 = P/F 200, 91% sensitivity with 56% specificity

Conclusion:
·S/F correlate with P/F
·S/F 235 and 315 correlate with P/F 200 and 300, respectively,for diagnosing and following up patients with ALI and ARDS




·SpO2 is also a good predictor of PaO2 up to saturation values of 97%

·S/F correctly classify severity rather than exactly predict PaO2 from SpO2





lung ultrasound for the 

detectionof bilateral

 opacities Improve 

the Radiographic 

Diagnosis of ARDS

Key point 4


Proportion of correct answers by study group: primary analysis and sensitivity analysis



·Ultrasound has good diagnosis accuracy for alveolar filling and consolidated lung in patients with ARDS by using bilateral worsening or loss of lung aeration defined by≥ 3B line per image between two ribs and /or consolidations
·More available but operating characteristics less well known and requires training in image acquisition

·To develop and validate a data-driven LUS score for diagnosis of ARDS using a diagnosis by an expert panel as the gold standard
·453 patients admitted to ICU and expected to be invasively ventilated ≥ 24h
-324 in the derivation cohort
-129 in the validation cohort



LUS-ARDS score is equally accurate for ARDS diagnosis as currently available methods



这样的结果可能告诉我们,超声会很快的帮助我们做诊断。

New definitions of ARDS LUS on the occurrence rate



·A post hoc analysis
·116 pats with any opacity on chest radiography but no ARDS according to the Berlin definition
·Abnormalities on LUS (B or C pattern, or posterior consolidation)
·Outcome: the occurrence rate of ARDS

·LUS detected bilateral abnormalities more often than chest radiography (86.2% vs 60.3%;p<0.001)
·28.4% with only unilateral opacities on chest radiography had bilateral abnormalities on LUS
·2.6% with bilateral opacities on chest radiography had only unilateral abnormalities on LUS

·33 (28.4%) pats had bilateral abnormalities on LUS and unilateral opacities on CRX
·12(10%) pats were ARDS using the new global definition




Resource-limited setting

Key point 5

·Screen every adult patient for hypoxia at a public referral hospital in Rwanda for six weeks

·Using Berlin criteria, no patients would have met criteria for ARDS

·Objectives: To estimate the incidence and outcomes of ARDS at a Rwandan referral hospital using the Kigali modification of the Berlin definition

-Without requirement for PEEP

-Without ABG, hypoxia cutoff of SpO2 /FIO2< 315

-With bilateral opacities on lung ultrasound or chest radiograph



·Forty-two (4.0%) of 1046 hospital admissions met criteria for ARDS
·Only 30.9% ARDS pats: admited to an ICU
·Hospital mortality 50.0%
·Using Berlin criteria, no patients would have met criteria for ARDS

Modified ARDS criteria: Kagali criteria



Primary Recommendations for the Global Definition of ARDS



新的标准让我们能够对于不插管的,比如原来我们只能诊断插管的病人,现在可以诊断经鼻高流量的病人,面罩的病人,甚至没有经鼻高流量病人,没有血气条件的病人。

The new criteria of ARDS reduced the severity of illness



·A retrospective cohort, including 3 databases
·4279 pats meeting the Berlin criteria
·4838 pats meeting new global definition

改善预后的方法可能是改变诊断标准。



ARDS vs. syndrome




·ARDS concenpt: it is time to change

·PEEP: Not only MV/NIV, but also HFNO >30L/min

·P/F: S/F when SpO2 <97%

·Pul infiltration: Not only chest X-ray or CT, but also Ultra-sound

·Resource-limited setting: PEEP and ABG--NOT necessary


Critical care and ICU 




参考文献


[1] JAMA. 2016. 315(8):788-800

[2] Recenti Prog Med.

[3] Lancet 2016 

[4] Thorac Dis 2018:10(9):5394-54

[5] JAMA 2012 Jun 20;307(23):2526-33.

[6] Intensive Care Med https:/doi.org/10.1007/s00134-020-06035-0

[7] JAMA. 2016;315(8):788-800.

[8] Lancet Respir Med. 2021;9(8):933-936

[9] Crit Care Med. 2016;44(1):120-9.

[10] Crit Care Med. 2018 :46(4):540-546.

[11] Australian Critical Care(2007)20, 126-131

[12] Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2022;205(4):431-439

[13] CHEST 2007;132:410-417

[14] Chest. 2016;150:307-13

[15] Lancet Respir Med. 2022;10(11):1086-1098

[16] CCM2019, DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000003000

[17] Curr Opin Crit Care. 2014:20(1):98-103.

[18] Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2023;207(12):1591-1601

[19] Crit Care Med. 2024:52(2):e100-e104.

[20] Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2016;193(1):52-59.

[21] Lancet Respir Med 2022;10:1086-98

[22] BMC Med. 2023;21(1):456




专家简介



重症学习
介绍,传播重症理念,知识,进展。欢迎一起学习!
 最新文章