GRE阅读只“判断”出逻辑关系远远不够!绝大部分阅读差的同学都是因为...

文摘   2024-10-14 19:01   北京  

GRE阅读非常看重对逻辑的理解。很多人以为的“理解逻辑”只是辨识出两个信息是什么关系,比如对比,比如支持,比如让步……

但其实“理解逻辑”绝不只是看出来这是什么逻辑,必须要明白这个逻辑为什么可以在这里存在,是什么信息使得这个逻辑能够成立。


🤔我这句话是什么意思呢?

比如:万蜀黍很优秀,但他是河南人。

看懂这句话,不仅仅是明白这里有个转折,而是要理解凭什么这里能有转折。如果说话者真的可以在这里安插一个“但”,他必须默认“河南人通常不优秀”,原来这是个地域歧视的说话者啊。这才叫真的理解说话者逻辑。

比如:万蜀黍很优秀,所以他肯定家境贫寒。

看懂这句话,不仅仅是明白这里有一个推理,而是要理解凭什么这里能有推理。如果说话者可以在这里安插“所以……肯定”,他必须默认“优秀的人家境贫寒”,这显然也是偏见。这才叫真的理解说话者逻辑。

逻辑关系有很多种,每种逻辑关系都有其成立的条件,我们今天在这里谈论最入门的逻辑——对立

当文章对两种特点进行对立,或者对两方观点进行对立,我们最关键的阅读意识就是要始终要求自己读出两方差异在哪里。

而且,非常常见的考法是,文章已经表达了要对AB两方进行对立,但接下来并不会详细描述AB各自的特点,而是只阐述一方的特点,比如说A具有特点P。

但我们必须记住文章的目的是要完成AB的对立,那么我们必须提醒自己补出B方的特点,它应该是P的对立面。而题目会经常考到文章没有说出来的那一边。

例题-1


Most seismologists assume that following a major earthquake and its aftershocks, the fault (a break in Earth’s crust where pressure can trigger an earthquake) will remain quiet until stresses have time to rebuild, typically over hundreds or thousands of years. Recent evidence of subtle interactions between earthquakes may overturn this assumption, however. According to the stress-triggering hypothesis, faults are unexpectedly responsive to subtle stresses they acquire as neighboring faults shift. Rather than simply dissipating, stress relieved during an earthquake travels along the fault, concentrating in sites nearby; even the smallest additional stresses may then trigger another quake along the fault or on a nearby fault. Although scientists have long viewed such subtle interactions as nonexistent, the hypothesis has explained the location and frequency of earthquakes following several destructive quakes in California, Japan, and Turkey.

Consider each of the choices separately and select all that apply.
The passage suggests that most seismologists believe which of the following about fault stresses?
A. They are dissipated when they result in an earthquake.
B. They are transferred between neighboring faults.
C. They will not cause a major earthquake along the same fault in the space of a few years.

答案

点击下方空白处获得答案

AC


解题思路:

这道题目大部分人都很容易选出C,毕竟题目问的是开头的科学家的想法,而C选项意思和the fault will remain quiet until stresses have time to rebuild是很一致的。

但大部分人会漏掉A选项,因为A的关键字出现在中段的“Rather than simply dissipating, stress relieved during an earthquake travels along the fault”。

这就是GRE真正考理解全篇关系的地方了。我们需要明白这部分信息是在对前面的科学家观点进行反驳,而这部分是在说“stress非但不会消散……”,而如果这部分信息能够对前面科学家的观点进行反驳,那前面必须默认的是“stress会消散”

所以A就必然是前文科学家所认同的想法。

例题-2


New underwater tunnel projects increasingly rely upon immersed tube technology, which involves digging a channel in the seabed and then sinking prefabricated tunnel sections into it. As well as being more resilient in earthquakes, immersed tubes are generally faster and less expensive to build than traditional bored tunnels. To begin with, problems with one section of tunnel won’t necessarily delay the entire project, and because immersed tubes can have a rectangular cross-section, they are a more efficient shape than circular tunnels for side-by-side railway lines. And while bored tunnels are usually considered stable only if their depth under the seabed at least equals their diameter, immersed tubes can sit immediately under the seafloor, allowing shallower approach gradients.

Consider each of the choices separately and select all that apply.
It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following is characteristic of bored tunnels?
A. They are the preferred option for crossing shallower spans of water
B. Their stability suffers if they are not built deeply enough
C. The shape of their cross-sections cannot be rectangular

答案

点击下方空白处获得答案

BC

解题思路:

这道题目很多人做起来也很痛苦,首先文章翻译好像就很难,那些术语都很不好理解。其实术语完全不重要,文章就是一堆符号。

关键是要明白,第一句话说了现在的tunnel用的叫immersed tube技术,而第二句说这种技术取代了先前的bored tunnels,这个时候对立已经出现。而下一句的关键逻辑提示to begin with以及再下一句开头的and表明,接下来两句话都是要展开这个对立

所以接下来的两句话必须要体现两种科技的对比,更准确来说,就是immersed tube相较于bored tunnels的优势。

于是,第二题考bored tunnels的特点,答案可以直接来自于文章中说bored tunnels的特点,也可以来自于文章中immersed tube的特点并进行取反。

显然,B对应了原文最后一句话bored tunnels are usually considered stable only if their depth under the seabed at least equals their diameter,这个对应是很直接的。

那C呢?
C对应的是倒数第二句话because immersed tubes can have a rectangular cross-section,这里虽然说的是immersed tube的特点,它可以是rectangular的,但因为这句话是在展现两种技术的区别,所以我们必须读出来这里默认了bored tunnels不能是rectangular的,所以C就选出来了。

今天的分享就到这里啦!万炜老师最新一期GRE阅读全程班即将开课(10月15日)

在GRE阅读全程班上,万蜀黍会带大家详细总结GRE阅读所有“逻辑关系”以及对应的信息处理方式;还有所有阅读考点和相应解题技巧~想要系统学习GRE阅读的童鞋不要错过!

可扫下方二维码添加助教咨询课程详情↓


青山学堂GRE
一站式GRE备考方案| GRE干货知识点| 高质量GRE机经真题
 最新文章